short fiction rejections

You are currently browsing the archive for the short fiction rejections category.

OY!  A non-encouraging rejection from a major house, the second rejection I’ve gotten from them.  I think I’m just shooting a little too high maybe.  Maybe I’m not established enough, maybe I’m not talented enough, maybe my style is not refined enough, maybe the things I write about are not epic enough…but I think I’m not going to submit to this major magazine again until I have some more credits to my name.  I suppose you can’t just come running out of the gate aiming for the gold medal or the pulitzer or whatever…well maybe some people can, but not me. 

I’m usually pretty good at letting these roll off me, but this one came at an inconvenient time…a time when my defenses were low…and so it seemed to hurt a little bit extra.

I’ve got one more piece out there in this rejection phase…and am still sitting on half a dozen, four of which are almost ready and two of which are not even close but are showing potential…

It’s funny, this magazine that just rejected me, in their most recent issue they had the most amazing short fiction piece I’ve probably ever read – really powerful – the kind of piece that makes you wish you’d written it, and short of that, the kind of piece that makes you wish you had the money to option things, and also the kind of piece that makes you wonder why you think you can compete. But they also had in the same issue a piece that I found to be totally pedestrian.  Totally not better than what I have submitted to them in the past (certainly not this time around) so it’s frustrating.  I suspect it will always be frustrating…successful or not…though I’d prefer to go with successful…

Updated Stats:  0 for 4 in Phase II with one submission still out there being considered and about six still prepping for submission (soon?).

Yup.  Another one.  Like I always say, painful little groups, rejections LOVE to come in painful little groups.  This one was from my beloved McSweeney’s (who I’m now 0 for 2 with – not including an award I submitted for and did not win, as expected).  This rejection is particularly unfortunate though because this piece is particularly odd and I’m not sure where else it could find a home…maybe Tin House?  We’ll see.

Updated Stats:  0 for 3 in Phase II, with two more pieces still out there being considered and between four and six being prepped for submission.

Hmmm.  Woke up today to a rejection email on my blackberry.  Not going to go down as one of my favorite ways to wake up.  It’s certainly not as good as Paul’s wake up to acceptance.  I like this piece that just got rejected, I think it’s pretty strong, for the first time I was actually surprised about a rejection (e.g. the piece was strong and the publication seemed right for it and not TOO respectable and difficult to get in to). 

Anyway, rejection rejection rejection…see they always come in painful little clumps.  I guess I should expect a few more this month.  I’ve got three more piece out there (one WAY overdue from McSweeney’s) awaiting rejection, and a handful of stories – between four and six that should go out for submission in the next month.  I’m going to try to stay focused on that…

Ah, rejection, how I love thee…wait, that’s not right.

I got my official rejection from McSweeney’s yesterday for their Amanda Davis Highwire Fiction Award.  It was a longshot anyway, but I’m still disappointed.

That leaves four short fiction submissions still out there for consideration, including one very overdue one to McSweeney’s Quarterly Concern.  With rejections having a nasty habit of coming in little painful groups I’ll be steeling myself up…

And so it ends.  I got my last short fiction rejection for the group of eight that had been sent out.  This rejection was from Zoetrope All-Story, and was fully expected, as Zoetrope is a literary magazine of the highest order – recently Wes Anderson had a piece published…WES ANDERSON!…I cannot compete with Wes Anderson! 

Ahem.  Anyway, so suffice to say I wasn’t surprised.  What did totally surprise me was the shockingly encouraging handwritten note on the back.  If you’re gonna get a rejection, that is the kind to get, so thank you Zoetrope, for um, rejecting me.

So I don’t feel so bad, and already have another piece in mind to revise and submit to them (even though it seems like aiming for the sun).  I’m actually in the process of editing/revising/rewriting a whole new batch and sending them out again. 

Wish me luck…and for the record, here’s the new count:

1 for 8

:(

Ah, sigh.  McSweeneys.

How I love thee.  How thou does not yet love me.

I got my rejection today from McSweeney’s for a story I submitted months and months ago, so I knew it was a no, but it was good to have the final word, if only so I can send that story back out.  It is one of my favorites, but I can see why it might not quite be a fit for my beloved McSweeney’s.  But it’s okay, I’ve been working on (in my mind only) another little story that might be great for McSweeny’s…just have to sit down and put pen to paper, or fingertips to keys…whatever. 

I have to say, one nice thing about a McSweeney’s rejection…it comes on an awesome little postcard (in my SASE of course so nobody can see my shame).  It was also fairly encouraging for a rejection letter.  I suppose I should have expected no less from them.

Okay, so the official count is now:  1 for 7

And that’s all that have gone out…I’m preparing a new group though.  Let’s hope these are more potent (or lucky).

When it rains, it pours.  I just got a rejection today, not really for short fiction but rather for a “list” that I submitted to McSweeney’s for their McSweeney’s Internet Tendency Lists.  I got a nice little email from them, but it was a rejection all the same.  Why is it rejections come in little painful groups?  It’s like the rejection people see you exposed and vulnerable from a previous recent rejection and think, “oh, now’s a good time to let her know…STRIKE NOW!”  It’s so frustrating.  So debilitating.  And I am barely in the infant stages of rejection…*sigh*

The official count, revised from yesterday to reflect this submission that I forgot about:  1 for 6

From Ploughshares.  Whee!

I had little hope for this piece as it’s a bit aggressive, but hey, you never know.  That leaves me with one piece still out there (to McSweeney’s) which I’m already kind of assuming is a no.  It’s time to get off my ass and start resubmitting and revising where necessary.  I got my copy of Tin House’s Fantasitical Women issue Saturday and spent all day kicking myself, because I had a really good piece for this, but missed the deadline. Ah, big sigh.

Anyway, here’s the official count:  1 for 5

Newer entries »